Evidence
Why this matters
Schools are often the first setting where traumatic exposure becomes visible in a child’s behavior, attention, emotional regulation, attendance, and learning. When school staff lack timely awareness that a student was exposed to a traumatic event, the response may move toward discipline instead of support. Handle With Care programs were created to close this gap by giving schools a minimal signal before the next school day, allowing staff to respond with care rather than react only to behavior. (1, 2)
What we know about trauma in schools
Childhood trauma can affect executive functioning, working memory, inhibitory control, cognitive flexibility, emotional regulation, behavior, attention, and learning. These effects can show up in school as withdrawal, difficulty concentrating, impulsivity, dysregulation, absenteeism, somatic complaints, or difficulty engaging with instruction. (3, 4)
This matters because trauma-related behavior is not always visible as trauma. Without context, adults may see only the behavior, not the underlying exposure. A timely notice does not diagnose the child or explain the incident. It simply gives the school enough awareness to pause, observe, and respond with appropriate support. (1, 2, 4)
What Handle With Care demonstrates
Handle With Care demonstrates that first responders can notify schools when a child has been present at or exposed to a traumatic event without sharing incident details. The core notice is intentionally minimal. In many models, it includes the child’s name and a signal phrase such as “Handle with care,” with no description of the incident. (1, 5, 6)
This “no details” boundary is central to the model. It preserves privacy, limits unnecessary information sharing, and keeps the school’s role focused on support rather than investigation. It also makes timely communication more feasible because the notice does not require schools to receive sensitive law enforcement, clinical, or family information. (1, 5, 6)
Handle With Care models also establish timing as a core operational requirement. Notices are intended to reach the school before the student returns, often before the next school day, so staff can respond supportively at the first point of contact. (1, 2, 5)
What current implementations show
Handle With Care has been implemented or documented in multiple jurisdictions, including West Virginia, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, Virginia, Florida, and New Jersey. These models share the same basic intervention logic: first responders identify child exposure, send a minimal notice, and schools respond through trauma-informed support. (1, 2, 5, 6, 7)
At the same time, implementation varies across jurisdictions. Notice routing may depend on email, fax, phone, text, dispatch relay, forms, or local points of contact. These differences create risks around timing, receipt, role clarity, auditability, and consistency. The issue is not whether the Handle With Care model is useful. The issue is whether the model can be standardized enough to function reliably across settings. (1, 2, 5, 6, 7)
Evidence boundary
Some sources report promising outcome data from early Handle With Care pilots, including reductions in suspendable issues and office referrals. However, because the strongest figures currently available are reported through secondary program sources rather than a primary evaluation, they should be treated as promising but not yet sufficient for strong public outcome claims. (8)
The strongest evidence for T.E.N. is therefore not a claim that traumatic exposure notices have already proven large-scale outcome effects. The stronger claim is narrower and more defensible: child trauma affects school functioning, timely awareness helps adults respond more appropriately, Handle With Care demonstrates that minimal notice is operationally feasible, and current implementations show a need for clearer standards, routing, and guardrails. (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7)
Sources
Handle With Care Oklahoma, “Program Overview.” https://handlewithcareok.org/program-overview/
SRI Education, “Evaluation of Handle With Care 2.0: Supporting Students Who Experience Trauma.” https://www.sri.com/education-learning/student-behavior/evaluation-of-handle-with-care-2-0-supporting-students-who-experience-trauma/
Teicher, M. H., Samson, J. A., Anderson, C. M., and Ohashi, K. “The effects of childhood maltreatment on brain structure, function and connectivity.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience / PMC. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6428430/
Common Trauma Symptoms in Students & Helpful Strategies for Educators. Oklahoma Turning Point Council / REL Appalachia.
New Jersey Office of the Attorney General, “Directive 2020-9: Handle With Care.” https://www.nj.gov/oag/dcj/agguide/directives/ag-Directive-2020-9_Handle-With-Care.pdf
Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office, “Handle With Care.” https://hwc.plymouthda.com/handle-with-care/
Handle With Care Florida, “Program Overview.” https://handlewithcarefl.org/program-overview/
Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office, Handle With Care program materials reporting Brockton pilot outcome data. https://hwc.plymouthda.com/handle-with-care/
Last updated

